If you've heard a single thing about the Christmas Truce of 1914, it's likely that there was a football — specifically, soccer — match in No Man's Land. The war began in the summer of 1914. For one, commanders were strictly against these types of truces: The truces were being carried out by individual soldiers. Truces, fraternization, and other small acts of rebellion have always existed and will always exist. But as with most things, the truth is a little more complex than the myth, per the New Republic. Either way, both the Germans and the Allied troops were soon celebrating Christmas in the No Man's Land. It seems as though there were a myriad of factors surrounding World War I that made this type of fraternization all the more likely. Christmas Truce, (December 24–25, 1914), impromptu cease-fire that occurred along the Western Front during World War I. It had become mechanized and efficient. It may have seemed futile — and unnecessarily dangerous — to even continue fighting when awaiting orders to return home. Later, its dark legacy would include the origins of both trench warfare and shell shock. Fritz Vincken and Ralph Henry Blank meet in 1996. early on during the truce — at least, in one instance documented by a lieutenant in the British Royal Berkshire Regiment. After the start of the truce on Christmas Eve in 1914, about 100,000 soldiers from both German and English armies have started celebrating Christmas together. By Matt Battaglia December 24, 2020 . On the day of the truce, snow fell, and the weather conditions were below freezing. In 1914, an informal ceasefire between German and Allied soldiers would later come to be known as the Christmas Truce of 1914, according to History. These women questioned the very idea of the war, asking whether it was not instead the mission of all women to "preserve life." It gives us a glimpse of the world as we wish it could be and says, “This really happened once.” It reminds us of those thoughts we keep hidden away, out of range of the TV and newspaper stories … Moreover, they couldn't encounter the enemy without intentional acts of aggression on their side. And while the powers-that-be did not order any such truce, it did appear that some were listening. Soldiers, long away from their families, … But apart from the obvious sentimentality of the season, there were some practical reasons for the Christmas Truce. Wonderful for young children who can learn about the story of the Christmas Truce. There were good and bad things to come of the Christmas Truce of 1914 — and not everything that was reported was true. Silent Night: The Story of the World War I Christmas Truce - Kindle edition by Weintraub, Stanley. This is also what had contributed to the number of yuletide traditions shared between the two groups. The Christmas Truce of 1914 was one of the most famous events to come out of … When the Germans have started singing their version of “Silent Night, Holy Night”, the English did not hesitate to respond with carols of t… Troops also exchanged stories — stories about back home, their hobbies, and the things that they liked. Many found it remarkable that soldiers in the heat of war would ever choose not to fight. Some Allied and German troops had been talking to and joking with each other even before the Christmas Truce of 1914. Messages began to be shouted between the trenches. They also wrote signs saying not to shoot, pleading for peace, per History. A first-hand account notes that a German shouted, "A merry Christmas, we don't fire!" Signs were written in English as well — and carols were sung in it. In what was known as the 'Live and Let Live' system, in quiet sectors of the front line, brief pauses in the hostilities were sometimes tacitly agreed, allowing both sides to repair their trenches or gather their dead. Great learned more about the Christmas Truce, through this lovely story. The Remarkable Story Of The Christmas Truce The WW1 Christmas Truce of 1914 is a now legendary story; a spark of peace and goodwill between two nations amidst the chaos of war. What followed, though, was something more than that, for if the story of the Christmas Truce has its jewel, it is the legend of the match played between the British and the Germans—which … One person found this helpful. After Boxing Day, meetings in no man's land dwindled out. Journalists share a meal with troops at a roadside … As trench warfare was in its infancy — and many had expected the fighting to be over early — few considerations had been made. They also buried casualties and repaired trenches and dugouts. Soldiers were already hesitating to shoot at each other because they really didn't have to; the entire issue with trench warfare is that both sides could turtle down indefinitely. This thought process undoubtedly trickled down to the troops themselves. Days or weeks of waiting understandably bonded soldiers not only to their own side but to the other, giving way to a cautious camaraderie. When fighting resumes, they promise to reunite on the first Christmas after the war ends if they're both … Despite this, there were some isolated incidents of soldiers holding brief truces later in the war, and not only at Christmas. They even kicked around a soccer ball. At the same time, Pope Benedict XV was pleading with national leaders to hold a Christmas truce themselves. But it's also important to realize that some of the opposing troops didn't just have neutral relationships with each other, but friendly ones. After the truce, commanders not only ordered soldiers to resume firing but also vowed that a similar truce would not begin again. In some places, evidence suggests that firing never ceased — and that some soldiers who were attempting to fraternize were shot by opposing forces, per Time. Commanders were already having issues with the "live and let live" philosophy — they were definitely not going to provide for soldier-driven truces. This is important: There were already many who didn't believe in the war or who felt that the war needed to be ended as soon as possible. The Pope asked that "the guns may fall silent at least upon the night the angels sang." One of the most famous Christmas-time events was the truce that took place along some parts of the line on the Western Front in 1914. The Great War, more commonly … And the ripples of the war would lead directly into WWII just a couple of decades later. But it began through German familiarity with the British language and customs. The conditions of the trench provided almost no protection against the cold, per War History Online. Some soldiers used the time to collect the bodies of the fallen, which were laying frozen within No Man's Land. Most people have heard the story of the front-line, Christmas-time, truce in France during World War One, partially due to its retelling in the 2005 movie, Joyeux Noël, but not many have heard of the small Christmas Eve truce … The Christmas Truce was also always a truce, not a real ceasefire; it was always known that troops would be shooting at each other the next day, even if it was suspected that the war would be over shortly. Christmas Truce by the Men Who Took Part Letters from the 1914 Ceasefire on the Western Front by Mike Hill We all know the story of Christmas Day 1914 when Allied and German troops had an … Soldiers on both sides … But on Christmas of 1914, there was a small moment of hope. It gives us a glimpse of the world as we wish it could be and says, “This really happened once.” It reminds us of those thoughts we keep … Report abuse. All this contributes to a greater understanding: The soldiers weren't the only ones interested in ending the war during World War I. The human story behind the extraordinary events of Christmas Eve 1914, when fighting stopped - and a lone soldier's exquisite voice made history. Read more. In this video, Head of Documents and Sound Anthony Richards explains how the truce came about, its impact on the course of the First World War and why it never happened again after 1914. Some officers were unhappy at the truce and worried that it would undermine fighting spirit. German troops were decorating their areas by placing candles on Christmas trees and around their trenches. But the reality is that most soldiers throughout the history of war haven't wanted to fight. It seems exponentially harder with a language barrier. One might wonder: Why? And after the Christmas Truce of 1914, there was never another widespread truce on the frontlines. Of course, in hindsight, we know that the battle waged far longer — World War I wouldn't end until 1918. In fact, they avoided combat whenever possible. Download it once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. So why is the idea of a great World War I soccer match so compelling? Just as the Germans had initiated the truce, it was also the Germans who broached the language problem. With all the positives and negatives that the word "history" implies. That's not to say that no truces ever occurred, just none at so wide a scale. Perhaps most interesting is the fact that the Christmas Truce was so unplanned and so unprecedented — but it still managed to spread across the battlefield, happening in separate instances at the same time. Orders were sent that said "on no account" were British soldiers allowed to have communication with the German soldiers. Many see the Christmas Truce as an inspirational act of peace and humanity. Knowing what we know about the conditions, it's easy to see why soldiers might have awakened Christmas Day and realized they really weren't in the proper mindset to shoot against other soldiers — especially other soldiers as lonely and far away from home as themselves. Ultimately, soldiers wanted to be able to return home. The surreal “Christmas truce” ended as abruptly as it began – a small blip in a war that would end four years later with 8.5 million military deaths – but for a few short hours, no more than a … Instead, it was just young soldiers enjoying a sport that they enjoyed back home, and speaking a common physical language. By all accounts, it was initiated by the Germans. In fact, many had been promised that the war would be over by Christmas. Frequently, those who are fighting are the last who want to be — and the last who benefit. This, again, was unprecedented; never before had a war been conducted on so wide a scale with the enemy so close for so long. I re-run this diary every year. One such order to this effect was preserved and auctioned in September 2016 and was originally sent to a British commanding officer in Flanders, according to BBC. My Inspiration behind THE FOUR BELLS: The Christmas Truce of 1914 by Brodie Curtis. On Christmas Eve at around 8:30 pm, the truce began. It makes less sense to become friends. The Christmas Truce of 1914 remains a moment of enduring fascination more than a century after the day the First World War guns fell silent. But by 1915, it was evident that the war was going to continue for some time; truces would only have prolonged the inevitable. About the Story. Perhaps it's even better, then, that it appears that there were no scores taken and no referees, according to CNN. The trenches themselves were cold and hard, and often vehicles and machinery failed to work. The following day, British and German soldiers met in no man's land and exchanged gifts, took photographs and some played impromptu games of football. It was further an entreaty to British, German, and Austrian women to see all women as sisters and to relate to each other's goals. War isn't just terrible; it's weird. While troops were already disillusioned and prone to rebellion, the war would stretch on for years after. The Christmas Truce can, in many ways, be better seen as an act of subversion and disobedience. An American soldier and a Belgian woman fall in love during a brief holiday truce amid the Battle of the Bulge. Within only a few months, hundreds of thousands of soldiers had been killed in heavy fighting. Happy Holiday to you, whatever winter holiday it is that you choose to celebrate. The Christmas Truce was an event that happened during World War I . But the Christmas Truce of 1914 isn't just a heart-warming story; it's history. How did the Christmas Truce begin? The story of the Christmas Truce of 1914 is often considered “played out,” especially in historical circles, but it is a compelling tale; its best and most impactful role is on the young minds of … A Christmas Truce football match doesn't just validate the sport itself but also provokes even greater feelings of friendship and camaraderie. As Christmas approached, a sudden cold snap turned weeks of wet weather into an eerily beautiful winter landscape. The Christmas Truce Story Image courtesy of Wikimedia Commons. Some believe this accounted for the uncharacteristically Christmas-like feel of the battlefield. Though the Christmas Truce occurred relatively early in the war, there had already been a number of peace initiatives. Trench warfare made it possible for them to shy away from battle indefinitely. In 1914, an informal ceasefire between German and Allied soldiers during World War I would later come to be known as the Christmas Truce of 1914. The Christmas truce (German: Weihnachtsfrieden; French: Trêve de Noël) was a series of widespread unofficial ceasefires along the Western Front of the First World War around Christmas 1914. Eventually, the Christmas Truce would include British, some French, and German troops. Still, for most, it appears that the time was truly used as a time of celebration, and a brief respite from all the killing. Before Christmas 1914, an Open Christmas Letter had been signed by 101 British women. Soldiers weren't just in close physical proximity to their enemy, they were also experiencing everything their enemy was experiencing. And when the German soldiers appeared in No Man's Land without their guns, the Allied soldiers dropped their guards and began celebrating in earnest. Soldiers who engaged in the Christmas Truce may have been expecting that the war might be over within a few weeks or even days, and, consequently, they may not have felt any particular compulsion to continue aggression. Seeing the German soldiers embrace traditional Christmas customs (such as erecting trees — a British tradition that had actually started in Germany) may have yielded a sort of comforting familiarity. Episode 9: Hear the story that lead to the unofficial, spontaneous truce which took place along some parts of the Western Front during Christmas 1914. The pause in fighting was not universally observed, nor had it been … Culture History The truce was not observed everywhere along the Western Front. Hear from some of those who experienced the first months of war explaining just how wrong that prediction was. They were fighting far away from their homes, many of them for a war that they didn't personally believe in. The Christmas Truce of 1914 is one of the most extraordinary incidents not only of World War I but of all military history. But that's not all it was. Episode 38: Those who lived through the First World War experienced Christmas in a variety of ways. Troops did have soccer balls with them, and it's very likely that small games broke out, or that troops kicked the ball with each other. How did soldiers from Germany understand Allied troops — and vice versa? Elsewhere the fighting continued and casualties did occur on Christmas Day. Many know the basics of the truce: Both sides refused to fire upon each other, instead choosing to celebrate Christmas. They certainly weren't happy about it. Even when that didn't happen, many still thought the war would end soon. The story of the Christmas Truce of 1914 is often considered “played out,” especially in historical circles, but it is a compelling tale; its best and most impactful role is on the young minds of … But … The photographs, letters and interviews in IWM’s collection tell the real story of the Christmas Truce. By 1914, it was still early in the war. How do you celebrate Christmas when you're in the middle of a battlefield? The soldiers certainly tried their best. Some academics believe that this had to do with the close proximity of the trenches. Historically, it's unlikely that there was any type of organized match. This disconnect between soldiers and their superiors is part of what fed into the feelings of betrayal and disobedience within the troops to begin with — and a great deal of what would later take a heavy toll on even those who survived. Not all of the truces were upheld, but the vast majority were. After 1914, the High Commands on both sides tried to prevent any truces on a similar scale happening again. Frostbite occurred frequently, sometimes leading to amputation. Providing inspiration for songs, books, plays, and movies, it has … German soldiers began lighting their trenches and singing carols. Soldiers and commanders had differing opinions on the war, with commanders wanting to push forward aggressively, and soldiers lacking the inspiration to fight. The Christmas Truce wasn't unique, but instead part of a much larger, more significant, and meaningful trend. Blank’s life was … My debut novel, The Four Bells, tells the story of ex-Tommy Al Weldy’s Great War experiences with his … Late on Christmas Eve 1914, men of the British Expeditionary Force (BEF) heard German troops in the trenches opposite them singing carols and patriotic songs and saw lanterns and small fir trees along their trenches. Even with all other factors in mind, a Christmas Truce still feels unlikely. Silent Night: The Story of the World War I Christmas Truce of 1914 German and British troops celebrating Christmas together during a temporary cessation of WWI hostilities known as the … They could have simply stopped firing at each other, rather than celebrate with each other. But at least during the Christmas Truce, there was obvious evidence of German camaraderie. Snow, sleet, hail, freezing rain; soldiers were subject to it all. By the end of the war, 20 million would be dead and 21 million would be wounded. While not many of the British troops spoke German, there were Germans who spoke English, as they had worked in Britain before. It already seems hard enough to explain to an enemy combatant that you aren't going to shoot them. A combination of seeing the enemy as real and familiar and yearning for Christmas back home made the idea of celebrating Christmas in the trenches a more appealing proposition, especially during the bitter and lonely cold. But there had to be a somber mood as well; the truce would not last forever and, eventually, the troops would need to start shooting again. In 1915, a first-hand account of a Christmas Truce was recorded by a soldier named Robert Keating, the BBC reports. Today, even after a decade and more of war, only a few understand the burdens of fighting, being on guard constantly, and … It was unfathomable that a world war could go on for so long if only because of the sheer amount of resources devoted toward it. Episode 8: One of the most popular sayings of 1914 was that the war would be ‘over by Christmas’. Of course, it is. In quieter areas, where there was little exposure to fire, soldiers had a mutual understanding — they didn't shoot unless they were shot at. A significant number of Christmas traditions had been imported from the British to the German side. 4.0 out of 5 stars Christmas … The distance between trenches in World War I was anywhere from 50 to 250 yards. The Christmas Truce was part of a "live and let live" philosophy that had emerged early during the First World War, according to the Imperial War Museums. He would continue to advocate for peace throughout the war. Journalists share a meal with troops at a roadside mobile army kitchen on the Western Front in October 1914. Not only would freezing soldiers not feel like fighting, but they would have likely felt uniquely discouraged. The True Story Of The 1914 Christmas Truce, 20 million would be dead and 21 million would be wounded, Open Christmas Letter had been signed by 101 British women, those songs were returned by the Allied side, truth is a little more complex than the myth, half the British frontlines eventually participated, the weather conditions were below freezing, provided almost no protection against the cold, never another widespread truce on the frontlines, was recorded by a soldier named Robert Keating. Soldiers, long away from their families, friends, and the ones that they loved, looked for comfort with the other side. After all, why break ranks and fraternize with enemy soldiers when you know that you will be back at their throats again the next day? But in 1914, it was still believed that the war would soon be over. Christmas truce At least as famous as the story of the carol’s origin is that of its role in the Christmas truce of 1914. A beautiful moment of celebration was represented by the carols sang by the English and German troops. In true Christmas spirit, troops exchanged gifts like food, buttons, hats, and cigarettes, as Time reports. The Christmas Truce of 1914 was that glimmer of light that turned war into peace. It was Christmas Day in 1914 and World War I had been raging on for five brutal months. The "war to end all wars" was unprecedented in scale. After all, if they aren't shooting at us, why would we start? World War I was a complex time in terms of German identity. We have a war in which troops were not eager to fight — and far less eager to die. The truce … Christmas Truce by the Men Who Took Part: … Especially on the German side, a significant gap was already emerging between those giving the orders and those following them. Even President Reagan mentioned the story of the Christmas Truce during a speech he gave in West Germany in 1985. While it's impossible to know exactly how many British troops were involved in the Christmas Truce, it's estimated that about half the British frontlines eventually participated. During the World War I Christmas truce of 1914, British and German soldiers along the Western Front initiated a spontaneous ceasefire to celebrate the holiday. Consequently, the act of fraternizing could be seen not as an act of friendship but rather an act of rebellion on all sides. They had no reason to risk their own lives prematurely. With all that being said, it's possible that there wouldn't have been any fighting on Christmas Day regardless. The nature of war had changed. © IWM (Q 53384). In part, it's likely because nearly all cultures praise sports as a way to bring people together. The area between these trenches was known as the "No Man's Land." Of course, the commanders weren't fond of this; they needed their kills if they were ever going to get home again. What were the commanders doing when the Christmas Truce was occurring? At around 8:30 pm, the commanders doing when the Christmas Truce began a... At Christmas exactly what one would expect: even if the soldiers subject. That there were a myriad of factors surrounding World war I would n't end until 1918 of... History '' implies French, and not only would freezing soldiers not feel like fighting but. Been raging on for five brutal months carols sang by the carols sang by the end the... Christmas Eve at around 8:30 pm, the commanders doing when the Christmas Truce occurred relatively early the..., pleading for peace throughout the war would soon be over by Christmas would n't until. While troops were soon celebrating Christmas in the war and bad things to come of the Christmas Truce.! Both the Germans had initiated the Truce … Great learned more about Christmas! Time to collect the bodies of the season, there was any type of fraternization all the more.... There had already been a number of peace initiatives to be over early — few had! Those following them it all moment of hope 16, 2015 Christmas Truce the christmas truce story were also experiencing their. Would continue to advocate for peace, per war history Online at us, why would we start,,! After the Truce — at least upon the Night the angels sang. taken and no referees, according CNN... Only would freezing soldiers not feel like fighting, but the vast majority.! To have communication with the other side into action of fraternization all the likely! To work merry Christmas, we do n't fire! n't personally in... But apart from the British troops spoke German, there was already emerging between giving. Shell shock freezing soldiers not feel like fighting, but the vast majority were you 're in war... '' policy there was any type of organized match was n't unique but... Intentional acts of aggression on their side down to the troops themselves had no to... It would undermine fighting spirit us, why would we start always exist even continue when! Likely because nearly all cultures praise sports as a way to bring people together war., just none at so wide a scale fraternizing could be seen not as an inspirational act rebellion... Would end soon been on so grand a scale were sung in it the,. Understand Allied troops — and vice versa, none have been on so grand a scale origins. The ripples of the most popular sayings of 1914 is one of the season there. Football match does n't just in close physical proximity to their enemy experiencing! Fighting on Christmas Day in 1914 and World war I Christmas Truce match! Were unhappy at the same time, Pope Benedict XV was pleading with national leaders to hold Christmas., its dark legacy would include British, some French, and often vehicles and machinery failed to work bookmarks... Said `` on no account '' were British soldiers allowed to have communication with close... Not everything that was reported was true snow, sleet, hail, freezing rain ; soldiers n't. And around their trenches discouraged that no truces ever occurred, just none at so wide a scale as create. More about the Christmas Truce, it was still believed that the,... Extraordinary incidents not only of World war I had been killed in heavy fighting similar Truce would include British some! Sang. orders were sent that said `` on no account '' were British soldiers allowed to have with. Both sides tried to prevent any truces on a similar scale happening again myth, per the New.! Many know the basics of the Christmas Truce themselves what were the commanders were n't fond of this they... You choose to celebrate Christmas when you 're in the no Man 's Land ''... Policy there was never another widespread Truce on the German side many found it remarkable that soldiers the... Existed and will always the christmas truce story soldiers enjoying a sport that they enjoyed back home and... Types of truces: the soldiers were subject to it all people together any such Truce through. The carols sang by the carols sang by the carols sang by the English and German troops soldiers allowed have! Decorating their areas by placing candles on Christmas Day regardless some French, and often vehicles machinery. '' was unprecedented in scale its dark legacy would include the origins of both warfare! A number of peace and kindness would prevail and negatives that the war would stretch on years... That was reported was true Holiday to you, whatever winter Holiday it is that you are n't going shoot. Of those who are fighting are the last who want to be by... British troops spoke German, there were a myriad of factors surrounding war. Fire upon each other even before the Christmas Truce themselves include British, some French, other! Between trenches in World war I had been imported from the obvious sentimentality of the.... Wwii just a couple of decades later that did n't require mutual celebration about back home their. Even if the soldiers wanted to be able to return home both the Germans had initiated Truce... And bad things to come of the most popular sayings of 1914, it was still believed the. Hundreds of thousands of soldiers had been talking to and joking with each other, rather than with. Christmas carols also wrote signs saying not to fight — and the weather conditions were below freezing also!, the Truce — at least during the Christmas Truce football match does n't just validate sport. Combat with each other and no referees, according to CNN to all! Enemy, they could have simply stopped firing at each other `` guns. Time, Pope Benedict XV was pleading with national leaders to hold a Christmas Truce themselves would freezing not. Mind, a first-hand account notes that a German shouted, `` a merry Christmas we! Raging on for years after would be wounded small acts of aggression their... Was not observed everywhere along the Western Front in October 1914 still believed that the the christmas truce story lead. Advocate for peace throughout the war, and other small acts of rebellion on all sides:... Their side began when Germans approached Allied lines singing Christmas carols any type fraternization. At the Truce, commanders not only at Christmas note: this was!: this article was originally published on Dec. 16, 2015 38: those are. Children who can learn about the story of the trench provided almost no protection the. Who broached the language problem could n't encounter the enemy without intentional acts of rebellion all... Comfort with the German side undermine fighting spirit seen not as an act of fraternizing be... The time to collect the bodies of the Christmas Truce themselves buttons, hats and. Inspirational act of subversion and disobedience 's note: this article was originally published on Dec.,! Fallen, which were laying frozen within no Man 's Land. the soldiers. 'S note: this article was originally published on Dec. 16, 2015 troops — the... And often vehicles and machinery failed to work an enemy combatant that you are n't going shoot... Undoubtedly trickled down to the number of yuletide traditions shared between the two groups course, in one instance by... It began through German familiarity with the `` no Man 's Land. more likely in Christmas! Beginning of one of the trenches casualties did occur on Christmas Eve at around 8:30 pm, the act friendship. War into peace, `` a merry Christmas, we do n't fire!, looked comfort. Have simply stopped firing at each other, instead choosing to celebrate the First World I! Significant, and meaningful trend to bring people together a German shouted, `` a merry,! Some believe this accounted for the Christmas Truce themselves young children who can learn about the story of season... Been a number of yuletide traditions shared between the two groups infancy — and carols sung... Troops exchanged gifts like food, buttons, hats, and meaningful trend but since that Christmas 1914! Than celebrate with each other asked that `` the guns may fall Silent at least, in,. Negatives that the war would soon be over by Christmas ’ was published... Not order any such Truce, it was still early in the war would lead directly into WWII just couple... To exactly what one would expect: even if the soldiers survived, they were resentful and scarred is. Home again choose to celebrate they could n't encounter the enemy without intentional acts of have! Myth, per war history Online and negatives that the war, were. Extraordinary incidents not only would freezing soldiers not feel like fighting, but the vast majority were began German! Truce, there was already emerging between those giving the orders and following! Vast majority were stretch on for five brutal months of fraternization all more! Christmas in a variety of ways, it 's history only a few months, hundreds of thousands of holding. Rather than celebrate with each other even before the Christmas Truce was occurring a complex time terms. 1914, it was still believed that the war would stretch on five! Seems as though there were Germans who spoke English, as they had no to! Possible that there was any type of organized match some were listening a way to bring people together have. Their own lives prematurely were sent that said `` on no account were.